The P220 wasnt SIG Sauers first handgun, but it sparked a more important development. As you can probably tell, the P220 SAO is my favorite in either caliber. MNGunTalk.com View topic - Sig P220 45 VS Colt 1911 Gov. 45 It doesn't appear to belong to anyone. Sig P220 Combat - Much lighter (follow ups are slightly slower, recoil is more jumpy), tougher and more durable, fits with my active rugged lifestyle, double action and stupid simple, easy to carry. I have a P220, Dan Wesson Specialist Commander sized 1911, and a CZ 97B. In your opinion, which frame handles the 10mm better? The 1911 is a legendary handgun, and it has been offered in many variations since its introduction 108 years ago. They shoot where you want and feed almost anything. With the success of the P220, SIG Sauer has cemented its position as a leading pistol manufacturer in the civilian market. However, the Sig Sauer P220 benefited from another 65 years of pistol evolution and got almost everything right from the start. We fixed it! Yell at me all you want, I know I'm right after years of using both platforms -- and here's my justification. Flawless and the weight results in 9mm-eque recoil. Colt 1911 They are different animals outside of the caliber. As far as capacity, nine rounds of .45acp are all that is needed out of a defensive pistol. SIG Sauer P220 Review: Old School Cool - Gun University The 220 carry is just a .45. Join 212,000 avid gun enthusiasts and claim your print-at-home shooting drills. In stainless, the full-size P220 is a fairly massive handgun, and feels far bigger and chunkier that the 1911. The original P220 was a 9mm and featured a heel clip magazine release. The guns recoil is minimal and best described with an Awe. The weight helps cut recoil, and the fat bottom grip helps displace it in the hand. A prolific author, Ayoob is the author of Gun Digest Book of Concealed Carry, Gun Digest Book of SIG-Sauer, Gun Digest Book of Combat Handgunnery, Massad Ayoob's Greatest Handguns of the World and many other books and more than one thousand articles on firearms, combat techniques, self-defense, and legal issues. Taking the gun apart is very easy, and SIG makes it simple. My fingertip falls perfectly on the trigger, but for many others, I imagine trigger reach is a bit far. Massad Ayoob. SigTalk is a forum community dedicated to SIG Sauer enthusiasts. In other words good workmanship is a plus but when coupled with cheesy materials and an inferior design it never has cut the mustard. Mfg: Viridian Weapon Technologies. I also have a P220 SAO Elite 10mm and a P220 SAO Legion in 10mm. I now own and carry a 220 Elite Dark. It is a beast, especially in its enclosed . The SIG Sauer P220 is a semi-automatic pistol. A Sig Sauer P220 only needs to be run one way: hammer down on a loaded chamber. Sig P220 Legion Full-Size. Sig Sauer Braided Recoil Spring, Suitable for: P220 chambered in 45acp-or-P226 chambered in .357sig / .40s&w This is a factory original Sig Sauer part. Itll probably keep you reasonably safe in a bullseye match but I still would lay odds that a nice P220 Match Elite will probably kick the crap out of a 1911 Gold Cup at the target range too. He deployed in 2009 to Afghanistan and again in 2011 with the 22nd MEU(SOC) during a record setting 11 months at sea. Now, lets look at plainclothes wear, whether in a detective assignment or off duty. The gun weighs 1.9 pounds unloaded. It is what it is. Pull the slide rearward until the half moon cut out of the slide is above the takedown lever. And I might add myself, This they accomplished at the expense of durability, along with an inferior design wrote with problems, most of which never have or in some cases impossible to, correct with its ill conceived design. Heres the short version answer why Sig P220 trumps the 1911: Now heres the long version of this bickering: Ive always been a Sig Sauer fan and it all started when I got my first Sig Sauer P226 then wandered over to the P220 in .45 ACP years ago. Police agencies across the U.S. and around the world have used, and still use, Sig pistols extensively. It was certainly truth in advertising. A Colt all steel Delta Elite would be hard to beat. Seller: Jones & Jones. A 400-dollar SIG is hard to beat. Please note we use stock pictures that is a representation of the item and may not be the exact picture due to manufacturers design change or simple a general picture or group picture with the item . They are two distinct animals other than the commonality of caliber. Total Windage Travel . It plowed through almost 300 rounds without so much as a hiccup or a cleaning. Romans 1:16- "For I am not ashamed of the Gospel of Christ" Do we not read throughout the Scriptures that Christ is the King? JavaScript is disabled. Best 1911 Pistols For the Money - Pew Pew Tactical Please dont give me that look, as if Ive lost my head. For a while, it came to the United States as a Browning BDA model. Sig borrowed the inferior mainspring position which resulted in the mainspring being positioned outside the back strap and covered only by the flimsy plasticky grips. I know the 1911 is Gods Gun (though I bet when I get to the Pearly Gates, Saint Peter will be rocking a Sig) and the physical manifestation of America! in forged steel. It comes down to whats more important for you, reliability/accuracy/ergonomics, or capacity/size? . This is a proven pistol that offers superlative reliability and surprising accuracy. With a 4.41-inch barrel, the SIG was a little longer in that dimension than the 4.25-inch Colt Commander, but more than half an inch shorter than the 5-inch Government Model. Some of us prefer the cocked and locked Model 1911 chambered in .45 ACP for carry. Maybe you handled a norinco rip-off, but the P220 is a dream and 100% opposite of your tedious description. Sig Sauer Recoil Springs - 14, 16, 18 and 20 Lbs.Fits all P220, P226, P227 models (DASA, SAO, Elite, Legion, 220/226 "S" etc.) In a fall or sudden impact the grips can shatter or crack and then the mainspring strut can become bent or even snapped in two putting the gun out of action. Brand - S - Sig Sauer - Sig Handguns - Sig Sauer P220 - Impact Guns Available in both carry and full-size, the legendary P220 lives on, allowing you to put all-metal power in your corner. While known more for their revolvers and M&P pistols, S&W should not be overlooked when it comes to 1911s. Its a locked-breech, short recoil-operated pistol that utilized SIGs own system. Its easy to reach, and the thumb can quickly drive it downwards. Hmmm, interesting. Have never found ANY other pistol capable of doing that, reliably, all the time. Thats cool; this article is my personal opinion. The SIG P220 is one of the flagship guns of the SIG Sauer handgun lines. With what's going on in the world these days I'd say get the 220. I prefer this design to something like Glock, which digs into my hand like crazy. The Commander, originally introduced in lightweight format in 1949, weighed 26.5 ounces unloaded and held the same number of .45, .38 Super, or 9mm rounds as the P220. ), load them in the magazine, and then feed them through the pistol, one after another. SIG SAUER's recoil springs fit any SIG SAUER pistol, rifle or other firearm. Or, hey, get yourself a P220SAO (single action only) or P220 with a DAK trigger. 10mm Pistol Comparison: Scoring & Ranking 4 Popular Models Four shots went into roughly 1-1/4 inches. (1) A fan of SIGs compact single-stack 9mm, Mullin added, Although the P220 is not as good as a P225, I would rate it the top weapon that I tested in .45 ACP. (Mullins emphasis.). (Though, oddly enough, 9mm, 10mm, .38 Super and .22LR are other available calibers for both pistols). It always had good sights compared to most of its competition. The P220 weighs a tad less than a lightweight Commander, 25.7 ounces unloaded. I believe there is now a relief in the frame in the form of a notch. Sig P220 45 Dark sig finish, 4.3" bbl . I have twice put five rounds from a P220 into one inch at 25 yards. Custom Fat Stainless Steel Guide Rod - Grayguns The distance the trigger had to move forward to re-set the sear was just enough to give a buffer against unintentional discharges under stress, but not so great that it appreciably slowed down the shooters rate of fire. The gun was and is extremely reliable. The only thing the P220 and 1911 share in common is caliber. Reliability * * * * *. The Sig P220 and the 1911 are both . The grip design overall is one of my favorites. If you've kept your P220 or P226 box stock without tweaks or upgrades, this is the correct replacement recoil spring because it provides the factory-spec 20 lbs. Although even with people who should know better, the gun has always been rated high in Snob Appeal (only because it was made in Germany originally) reality is another story. Just letting you know.Yes, overall rating the Sig P220 wins the minds of most shooters. Of the three the CZ 97 is my favorite by a good bit. However, in the wide world of guns, its universal that you do indeed get what you pay for. Developed by the German-Swiss arms manufacturer Sig Sauer for the competition to replace the M1911A1, the P226 had come in second place to the M9. This first reason a Sig P220 is better than a 1911 is a no-brainer. The Glock is a striker fired, DAO pistol. Bugs me too! Please consider creating a new thread. FCU Spells Freedom: Testing the Sig Sauer P365 Fire Control Unit They all worked just fine afterwards. The Sig P220 was the same basic concept as the Colt: a single-stack .45 ACP full sized combat pistol. See less See more Reply. Its time to look at another popular debate. I can tell you from extensive experience with both platforms that the Sig P220, no matter its vintage, will run pretty much whatever ammo you can put through it like greased corn runs through a goose. It's a heavy beast best described as a boat anchor. They are very similar and also very different. The author has seen duty belts weighing in the 15- to 20-pound range once festooned with multiple handcuffs, a full-sized baton, heavy flashlight, portable radio, and ammunition. The nice thing is since you have a 226 things will be the same. In my own testing although accuracy was good (at least with the German Made guns) the P226 9mm was always inferior to old fashioned classic guns like the Original High Power or Neuhausen P210 or CZ 75 or THE FABULOUS STAR MODEL 30 which was the BEST HANDGUN OF THE 20TH/21st.CENTURY which actually endured 180,000 round wear tests, try that with any other modern plasticky or stamped sheet metal pistol. The temptation is overwhelming to bestow it on somebody.". Youtube has de-funded most gun content. This is the standard Nitron finish P220 Carryas good as it gets for personal defense. Furthermore, its mechanical performance leaves nothing to be desired. Not a bad article, but anytime flat statements are made, reasonable people must speak up, Id put a P220 up against any new .45 on the market with complete confidence. Sig Sauer Guide Rods and Parts - Top Gun Supply The lightweight Commander was dubbed by one of its greatest advocates, Col. Jeff Cooper, as a gun designed to be carried much and shot seldom. Most who had fired it considered it much more unpleasant to shoot than its big brother, the full-sized, all-steel Government Model. The original hammer/trigger system was made not of high grade bar stock or forged parts but of a cheesy powdered compressed metal (sintered) later to be replaced presently with and even worse set of parts, the disastrously inferior MIM cast parts guaranteed to go snap, crackle and pop at the most inopportune times. Have not had an issue with shooting either one and I enjoy both, fell in love with the P220 when they first came out. Youtube has de-funded most gun content. Comparing two awesome .45 ACP pistol designs for SHTF. In the 90s the gun community widely reported both the Colt Delta Elite and S&W FBI 1076 pistols couldn't hold up to full power 10mm- there were numerous frame failures and the FBI sent back many if not most of their new 1076 models for this reason. Internally, Sig's new compact cannondubbed the "P245"shared little with the P220. I know that P220 would be in my hand faster than you could say, tap-rack-bang.. I have both a Colt Delta Elite and a. I checked my gun safe and I have to stand both corrected and chastised regarding my original post. Taken into service as the "Automatic Pistol, Caliber .45, M1911," it would go on to become the most respected combat handgun of all . Length & Weight. Designed in 1975 by the SIG Arms AG division of Schweizerische Industrie Gesellschaft (now SIG Holding AG), and produced by J. P. Sauer & Sohn, in Eckernfrde; it is currently manufactured by both SIG Sauer companies: SIG Sauer GMBH, of Eckernfrde, Germany; and SIG Sauer, Inc., of New Hampshire, United States.